Search locations or food
OR
Sign up

13 Worst Rated American Salads

Last update: Sat Apr 19 2025
13 Worst Rated American Salads
VIEW MORE
01

Salad

UTAH, United States of America
2.5
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Frog eye salad is a flavorful concoction made with the ball-shaped acini di pepe pasta, egg yolks, and a whipped cream topping that can sometimes be enriched with the addition of pineapple pieces, shredded coconut, mandarin oranges, or marshmallows.


This crossover between a pasta salad and a fruit salad is especially popular in Utah, where it is a staple at potlucks.

MOST ICONIC Frog Eye Salad

1
2
02

Salad

PENNSYLVANIA, United States of America
2.9
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Amish pasta salad is a traditional dish originating from Pennsylvania Dutch Country, where the Amish people live and work. Although there are variations, the pasta salad is usually made with a combination of macaroni, scallions, bell peppers, hard-boiled eggs, and celery.


The ingredients are mixed and dressed with a mixture of mayonnaise, crème fraîche, mustard, sugar, white wine vinegar, celery seeds, salt, and pepper. Once all the ingredients have been coated with the dressing, the pasta salad is placed in the fridge to cool before serving. 
03

Salad

SAN FRANCISCO, United States of America
3.0
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Crab Louie is an American salad dating back to the beginning of the 20th century. The salad is prepared with a combination of Dungeness crab meat, tomatoes, iceberg lettuce, asparagus, hard-boiled eggs, and Louie dressing (based on chili sauce and mayo), while olives, green onions, and bell peppers are optional, but can be added if desired.


The origins of the dish are quite murky, but many sources claim that the dish was served as early as 1914 in a San Francisco restaurant called Solari's. This tasty salad is mostly served as an appetizer.

MOST ICONIC Crab Louie

View more
1
2
3
4
5
04

Salad

HAWAII, United States of America
3.1
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Usually an obligatory element of the Hawaiian plate lunch, macaroni salad is a slightly tangy, sweet, cold salad consisting of overcooked elbow macaroni pasta dressed with milk-thinned mayonnaise. The pasta must be overcooked as it helps absorb the dressing.


Some sources say that the earliest recipe for macaroni salad was published in 1962, and the dish gained popularity in the early 1980s as a part of the Nouvelle Cuisine approach, while other sources say that the dish was popular throughout Mainland America in the early 20th century. 

MOST ICONIC Macaroni Salad

View more
1
2
3
4
5
05

Salad

NEW YORK CITY, United States of America
3.2
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

A chef's salad is a big salad that is usually served as a meal of its own. It consists of a variety of vegetables, hard-boiled eggs, cheese, and meats such as ham or turkey meat. The salad can be served with a variety of different dressings. No one can agree about the origins of chef's salad, so there are quite a few theories about its invention.


Some claim that it originated from salmagundi, a 17th-century dish consisting of anchovies, chopped meat, eggs, onions, and oil. Others claim that Cobb salad was the true inspiration, while most believe that chef's salad was created in the 1940s by Louis Diat, a chef at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in New York City. 
06

Salad

PITTSBURGH, United States of America
3.2
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Pittsburgh salad is a twist on a traditional salad, originating from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The salad consists of a bed of lettuce that's topped with tomatoes or other vegetables, a piece of beef steak or grilled chicken, and crispy french fries.


The salad is traditionally sprinkled with shredded cheese such as cheddar or mozzarella and drizzled with dressing (usually Ranch) before serving. It's recommended to serve the dressing on the side, and it's then used as a dip. The potatoes can be regular french fries, waffle fries, wedges, shoestring fries, or curly fries. 
07

Salad

LEXINGTON, United States of America
3.2
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Red slaw is a regional version of coleslaw, originating from North Carolina. Also known as barbecue slaw, it's traditionally made with a combination of shredded green cabbage, water, vinegar, sugar, and ketchup, which gives the salad a reddish hue.


Red slaw is especially popular in Lexington, where it's served as a part of Lexington-style barbecue. The salad is also often used in hot dogs and sandwiches made with barbecued meat. Depending on the area, red slaw might contain other ingredients such as mustard seeds, black pepper, onions, carrots, or hot peppers, but what's important is that red slaw is always served well-chilled.

08

Salad

KENTUCKY, United States of America
3.3
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Wilted lettuce is a traditional dish of the American South. This salad is made with shredded wilted lettuce, chopped green onions, salt, and pepper. The ingredients are tossed, then mixed with a dressing consisting of apple cider vinegar and melted bacon drippings.


Southern wilted lettuce should be served immediately after it's been prepared. It's recommended to serve it with cornbread or corn muffins on the side. The dish is also known as kilt lettuce or killed lettuce, referring to the way the lettuce will soften under the hot dressing.

09

Salad

NEW YORK, United States of America
3.5
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Originating from the Dutch term koolsla, meaning cabbage salad, coleslaw is nowadays a true American staple and a side dish that's often served with barbecued meat or fried chicken. Originally, it was brought over to New York state in the 18th century by the Dutch settlers.


It consists of shredded cabbage, mayonnaise, carrots, buttermilk or sour cream with vinegar, sugar, and other seasonings, depending on the cook and regional variations. Some of the variations have other ingredients such as salad dressings, celery seeds, grated cheese, pineapple, or peppers. 
VARIATIONS OF Coleslaw

MOST ICONIC Coleslaw

View more
1
2
3
4
5
10

Salad

NEW YORK CITY, United States of America
3.5
Ate it? Rate it
Wanna try?
Add to list

Waldorf salad had been invented in 1896 by Oscar Tschirky, a dining room manager at New York's Waldorf-Astoria Hotel. Originally, the salad consisted of apples, celery, and mayonnaise, and was a huge success. Interestingly, finely chopped walnuts were added to the salad much later, in 1928, although most people associate the salad with walnuts as the key ingredient.


Today, Waldorf salad is usually served cold as an appetizer, on a bed of lettuce, while ingredients such as chicken, raisins, or grapes are sometimes added in the modern versions of this elegant dish.

MOST ICONIC Waldorf Salad

1
11
Salad
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
3.5
12
Salad
LOS ANGELES, United States of America
3.7
13
Salad
TEXAS, United States of America
3.8

TasteAtlas food rankings are based on the ratings of the TasteAtlas audience, with a series of mechanisms that recognize real users and that ignore bot, nationalist or local patriotic ratings, and give additional value to the ratings of users that the system recognizes as knowledgeable. For the “13 Worst Rated American Salads” list until April 19, 2025, 1,031 ratings were recorded, of which 970 were recognized by the system as legitimate. TasteAtlas Rankings should not be seen as the final global conclusion about food. Their purpose is to promote excellent local foods, instill pride in traditional dishes, and arouse curiosity about dishes you haven’t tried.

Show Map
American Salads